Senate blocks resolution demanding State Department report on Israel's human rights record
The Senate on September 29, 2026, declined to take up a resolution that would have required the State Department to give Congress a detailed report on Israel's human rights practices. Senators voted 47 to 51 against a motion to discharge the Senate Foreign Relations Committee from further consideration of S.Res. 852, so the measure did not advance to a full vote.
The vote was procedural. Under Section 502B(c) of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961, a single senator can file a privileged resolution seeking a State Department report on the human rights record of a country receiving U.S. aid, and after a set number of days it is guaranteed a floor vote. The motion to discharge was the step needed to bring S.Res. 852 out of committee; because it failed by four votes, the resolution was not taken up.
S.Res. 852, introduced on September 14, 2026, by Senator Chris Van Hollen along with Senator Tim Kaine, Senator Bernie Sanders and more than 20 other cosponsors, would have requested that the Secretary of State provide an unclassified statement to the Senate Foreign Relations Committee and the House Foreign Affairs Committee within 30 days. The resolution specifies that the statement should include credible information about the alleged killing of nine named U.S. citizens by the Israel Defense Forces, other Israeli security forces, or Israeli settlers since January 2022; the status of any investigations; an assessment of U.S. citizens held in Israeli prisons; and a description of the human rights situation of Palestinian children held in Israeli military detention in the West Bank.
Supporters framed the resolution as a demand for basic accountability for American deaths. Van Hollen said that "in just over 4 years, nine American citizens have been killed in the West Bank by violent Israeli settlers or members of the Israeli security forces, and there has been zero — zero — accountability." He argued the measure "simply requires a report — a report on what the U.S. Government is doing to protect its own citizens." Sanders, who introduced the first such resolution on Israel in January 2024, urged a "yes" vote, saying Americans "are becoming more and more disgusted and are demanding that the U.S. Congress act." Kaine, describing Israel as "a friend" and "an ally," said the resolution was necessary because "even though the United States is Israel's most important security partner, they are completely ignoring us when we raise important human rights issues such as this one."
Opponents argued the resolution was a one-sided attempt to undermine a U.S. ally. Senator Steve Daines called it "a misguided resolution," saying "the sole objective here is not justice or accountability for Americans, it is to cut off security aid to our ally Israel in its time of need." He said the measure "shames one of our strongest allies and minimizes the Palestinian Authority's role in inciting terrorist violence," and urged colleagues to vote no "so we can stand with our ally Israel as they beat back the scourge of Iranian-backed terrorism." Daines said that any loss of American life is a tragedy and that Ambassador Mike Huckabee had called for an investigation into the deaths, expressing confidence that the administration "will get to the bottom of this issue."
The 47 senators voting to discharge the resolution were all Democrats, joined by Senator Rand Paul, a Republican. Two senators did not vote.
How your senators voted
See how your senators voted
Use your Google, Microsoft, or Apple sign-in to get to your Project Euthyna account. If you don’t have one yet, we’ll create it. We store the census block you live in, and use it to work out who represents you. We do not store your address. We do not sell anything about you, and you can delete your account, and everything in it, whenever you want.
Continuing means you accept our terms of service and privacy policy.